# Answer to Puzzle #49: Fork in the Road

49. You reach a fork in the road. A sign explains that in one direction is Heaven and the other is Hell. Each path is blocked by a Guard. The sign goes on to say that one of the guards will always lie and the other will always tell the truth, it does not say which guard is which. We assume that the guards do know which path leads to where.

You may ask one question of only one guard in order that you can determine, with certainty, the way to Heaven. What is that question?

You may ask one question of only one guard in order that you can determine, with certainty, the way to Heaven. What is that question?

I get asked this question all the time. I've resisted including it because I think it's so well known that most of you will already know the answer. But it's here now:

Before reading the answer can I interest you in a clue?

There are lots of set ups for this puzzle. Two paths, two doors, heaven and hell, a lion and a kitten etc. The idea is always the same that there are two guards, one permanent liar, and one permanent truth teller both of which know the correct method of achieving something desirable and you must use logic and one question to retrieve that information.

We have seen the usefulness of permanent liars before, for example in the riddle of the incorrectly labelled coffee machine, what they tell us is not useless. We know it is wrong, which tells us something.

The procedure here is simple. We ask the guy on the left what the guy on the right would say. And then do the opposite, (to what he says).

Alex is the liar - Bob would have told you the truth, Alex knowing this, lies about it and tells you the wrong way.

Bob is the liar - Bob would have lied to you, Alex knowing this, tells you honestly the wrong way.

By asking one person what the other would suggest we have eliminated the uncertainty of who is the liar and ensured that there is always a lie present in our response.

An old puzzle but a good one. You can think of it as multiplying by a negative number. We have a negative times a positive, or a positive times a negative. Which is always a negative.

There are lots of set ups for this puzzle. Two paths, two doors, heaven and hell, a lion and a kitten etc. The idea is always the same that there are two guards, one permanent liar, and one permanent truth teller both of which know the correct method of achieving something desirable and you must use logic and one question to retrieve that information.

We have seen the usefulness of permanent liars before, for example in the riddle of the incorrectly labelled coffee machine, what they tell us is not useless. We know it is wrong, which tells us something.

The procedure here is simple. We ask the guy on the left what the guy on the right would say. And then do the opposite, (to what he says).

## Why does this work?

So we ask Alex what Bob would say. There are two possibilities:Alex is the liar - Bob would have told you the truth, Alex knowing this, lies about it and tells you the wrong way.

Bob is the liar - Bob would have lied to you, Alex knowing this, tells you honestly the wrong way.

By asking one person what the other would suggest we have eliminated the uncertainty of who is the liar and ensured that there is always a lie present in our response.

An old puzzle but a good one. You can think of it as multiplying by a negative number. We have a negative times a positive, or a positive times a negative. Which is always a negative.

## Assumptions

The major assumption here I suppose is that each guard knows the status of the other guard. I think it's probably only down to a lack of rigour or an attempt to reduce the verbosity, that it is not in the question.© Nigel Coldwell 2004 - – The

**questions**on this site may be reproduced without further permission, I do not claim copyright over them. The

**answers**are mine and may not be reproduced without my expressed prior consent. Please inquire using the link at the top of the page. Secure version of this page.

__PayPal__

I always think it's arrogant to add a donate button, but it has been requested. If I help you get a job though, you could buy me a pint! - nigel