Answer to Puzzle #51: Three Way Duel or Truel
I've been wrestling with this for a while because I couldn't find a way to explain the Maths:
Lets start with the answer. You may think the options available to Alice are to either aim at Bob or Cheri. Perhaps given that Cheri is the better shot Alice should aim at her. Alice is in fact better off deliberately missing until one of the other players dies. The other players of course, will target each other until one of them dies as the rational thing to do is to shoot the greatest threat, which for Cheri is Bob and Bob is Cheri.
Before we work the maths I have written what I believe to be the only three way duel or truel simulator. Have a play. If you want to know more about it click here.
With the default numbers my computer will run about 800,000 times in 1s, my phone 80,000. Running times vary significantly from browser to browser, (right now IE11 is faster than Chrome 45 and FF39), and depending on your hardware. Any more questions feel free to ask.
Probability of B hitting
Probability of C hitting
Time to Run milliseconds
Aim at B until they die
Aim at C until they die
Miss till someone dies
Essentially Alice, whatever she does, is going to find herself in a two person duel with Bob or Cheri. Even if she were to aim at someone and kill them, say she aims at Bob and hits, she is now in a two person duel with Cheri and it's Cheri's shot. Alice is dead. If however, she aims at nothing, after Bob or Cheri kill one or the other it is Alice's shot. And it is the first shot advantage that makes missing worth while. Lets move on to calculating this...
Solution to a Two Person DuelSometimes the probability of who survives a duel is easy to calculate say Bob and Cheri with Bob to shoot first. 2/3 chance Bob hits and wins, if not Cheri definitely hits and wins. This calculation is easier because Cheri is a sure shot and the game cannot go for another round. Otherwise though the generalised for looks like this:
Let p(X,Y) be the probability of X surviving a duel with Y where X has first shot-
p(X,Y) = Pr(X hits Y) + Pr(X misses Y) * Pr(Y misses X) * p(X,Y)Which is essentially the probability of X killing Y in the first shot plus the probability of nobody being killed and the whole thing happening again.
p(X,Y) where Y has the first shot could reasonably be surmised to be 1 - p(Y,X) since only one person can survive a two person duel. or explicitly
p(X,Y) = Pr(Y misses X) * (Pr(X hits Y) + Pr(X misses Y) * p(X,Y))
For example p(Alice,Bob) the probability that Alice wins a two person duel against Bob where Alice has the first shot:
p(Alice,Bob) = Pr(Alice hits Bob) + Pr(Alice misses Bob) * Pr(Bob misses Alice) * p(Alice,Bob) p(Alice,Bob) = 1/3 + 2/3 * 1/3 * p(Alice,Bob) p(Alice,Bob) = 1/3 + 2/9 * p(Alice,Bob) 7/9 * p(Alice,Bob) = 1/3 p(Alice,Bob) = 3/7All of the other calculations are similar. For convenience we will express the probabilities as fractions of 21, the lowest common denominator. If it's not clear the underline denotes first shot.
p(Alice,Bob) = 3/7 = 9/21 p(Alice,Cheri) = 1/3 = 7/21 p(Alice,Bob) = 1/7 = 3/21 p(Alice,Cheri) = 0 = 0/21
Remember Alice is going to be in a two person duel with one or the other of Bob and Cheri she has some control over who she fights, with the advantage being in fighting Bob rather than Cheri. But she has ultimate control over whether she has first shot. By not shooting anyone she can ensure that she has the first shot, and from the table it is clear that the first shot advantage is greater than the advantage of facing Bob over Cheri.
Back to the TruelNow we have decided that Alice is going to miss we can calculate the odds of her survival. Bob and Cheri will be involved in a two person duel, survivor to face Alice with Alice to shoot first. We don't need to use the formula to work out the odds of Bob or Cheri surviving, it's trivial. There is a 2/3 chance of Bob killing Cheri, if he doesn't he dies with the return shot.
p(Alice survive) = 2/3 * p(Alice,Bob) + 1/3 * p(Alice,Cheri) = 2/3 * 3/7 + 1/3 * 1/3 = 6/21 + 1/9 = 18/63 + 7/63 = 25/63 ≅ .3968
Remaining calculationsThe remaining probabilities are worth a quick look. Easiest is Cheri. She has a 1/3 chance of surviving the duel with Bob, the a 2/3 chance of surviving her duel with Alice. Which is 2/9 or 14/63 ≅ 0.2222. Which leaves Bob with 24/63 ≅ 0.3810
Nice puzzle this once you break it down.
AssumptionsAssumptions here are things that we assume are omitted from the question for brevity or neatness. Such as there are no stray bullets. All hits are fatal etc. The phrase 'three smart people' or some versions say 'three logicians', is meant to indicate that the players will act rationally. That is to say Bob and Cheri will shoot at the person who poses the greatest threat. Again we assume that they know the relative skills of each player. Some versions will say something like 'Alice who is known to be a poor shot...'
© Nigel Coldwell 2004 - – The questions on this site may be reproduced without further permission, I do not claim copyright over them. The answers are mine and may not be reproduced without my expressed prior consent. Please inquire using the link at the top of the page. Secure version of this page.
I always think it's arrogant to add a donate button, but it has been requested. If I help you get a job though, you could buy me a pint! - nigel